Friday, December 17, 2010

The Kroog Versus The Amazing Disappearing Crisis

Paul Krugman details the Republican efforts to absolve Wall Street of any and all wrong doing in the financial crisis by literally eliminating the words "Wall Street" from their report on the meltdown.  The Republicans on the government's Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission have decided to issue their own report, because how dare anyone blame our kindly banking overlords for the trillions they cost us?


Last week, reports Shahien Nasiripour of The Huffington Post, all four Republicans on the commission voted to exclude the following terms from the report: “deregulation,” “shadow banking,” “interconnection,” and, yes, “Wall Street.”

When Democratic members refused to go along with this insistence that the story of Hamlet be told without the prince, the Republicans went ahead and issued their own report, which did, indeed, avoid using any of the banned terms.

That report is all of nine pages long, with few facts and hardly any numbers. Beyond that, it tells a story that has been widely and repeatedly debunked — without responding at all to the debunkers.

In the world according to the G.O.P. commissioners, it’s all the fault of government do-gooders, who used various levers — especially Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-sponsored loan-guarantee agencies — to promote loans to low-income borrowers. Wall Street — I mean, the private sector — erred only to the extent that it got suckered into going along with this government-created bubble.

It’s hard to overstate how wrongheaded all of this is. For one thing, as I’ve already noted, the housing bubble was international — and Fannie and Freddie weren’t guaranteeing mortgages in Latvia. Nor were they guaranteeing loans in commercial real estate, which also experienced a huge bubble.

Beyond that, the timing shows that private players weren’t suckered into a government-created bubble. It was the other way around. During the peak years of housing inflation, Fannie and Freddie were pushed to the sidelines; they only got into dubious lending late in the game, as they tried to regain market share
.
But the G.O.P. commissioners are just doing their job, which is to sustain the conservative narrative. And a narrative that absolves the banks of any wrongdoing, that places all the blame on meddling politicians, is especially important now that Republicans are about to take over the House. 

Barry Ritholtz has the report here.  It's good old Soviet-style "truth", and it begins with a two-word sentence:

"Bubbles happen."

You can pretty much skip the rest of it.

4 comments:

  1. Zandar's Credibility ProblemDecember 17, 2010 at 8:49 AM

    So Zandar is upset because the Republicans got their facts wrong?

    That's fucking hysterical!

    You make this so easy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Way to copy/paste! I'm out of cookies, so you get a gold star.

    The one-trick pony schtick is tiring though.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i don't even bother to click on their links anymore. what on earth do these guys think they're accomplishing here?

    ReplyDelete
  4. If you can't bury them with facts, bury them with bullshit.

    ReplyDelete