Kansas Republicans have finally passed their nearly $400 million tax hike on the state's working class to make up for the hundreds of millions in the hole that GOP Gov. Sam Brownback's tax cut for the rich and businesses created, in an effort to avoid even more draconian cuts to schools and universities.
Kansas will avoid massive budget cuts after a tax plan crawled to passage in the Legislature on Friday, but some lawmakers who voted for the plan say the state has failed to right its financial ship.
Many lawmakers — including ones who supported the bills — accused Gov. Sam Brownback of bullying lawmakers into accepting a flawed plan.
Republicans, who hold supermajorities in the Kansas House and Senate, found themselves bitterly divided on taxes for weeks in the face of a $400 million budget hole as the legislative session stretched to 113 days, the longest in state history.
The House scraped together the 63 votes needed for passage at 4 a.m. Friday, passing a plan that raises $384.4 million in tax revenue, after working around the clock since Wednesday night. Several lawmakers who voted for the plan were moved to tears before Rep. Blake Carpenter, a Derby Republican, cast the deciding vote.
Little more than 12 hours later, the Senate approved the plan with 21 votes, again the bare minimum for passage, after an emotional debate. But even some lawmakers who voted in favor of the plan argued that it failed to address the cause of the state’s financial woes.
Sen. Jeff Longbine, an Emporia Republican, accused the Brownback administration of perpetrating “political blackmail” in recent weeks by threatening to veto any plan that rolled back an income tax exemption for certain businesses. That exception was passed in 2012 and removed more than 330,000 business owners from income tax rolls.
“This fix doesn’t fix the problem,” Longbine said. “If you’ve got congestive heart failure, you go to the cardiologist and not the dentist.”
The 2012 tax bill also eliminated the top tax bracket and cut all income tax rates. Longbine pointed out that it has already cost the state more than $1 billion, but argued that the plan passed by the Legislature through a pair of tax bills Friday failed to address that impact.
The measures will instead raise the sales tax to 6.5 percent from 6.15 percent in July and hike taxes on cigarettes by 50 cents per pack to help balance the state’s budget.
Longbine said he wanted to watch the plan burn but voted in favor of it to prevent cuts to the state’s schools, universities and disability services.
Brownback had warned that if lawmakers did not pass a tax plan before Monday, then he would make massive budget cuts — either issuing a 6.2 percent across-the-board cut costing schools nearly $200 million, or line-item vetoes of budgets for the state’s regents universities.
The Kansas disaster continues, and I'm betting that the hike in sales and vice taxes, a regressive taxation scheme targeting the poor and working class, won't bring in the projected revenue just as the massive tax cuts on the wealthy didn't magically create new revenue either. Somehow I bet Topeka will be right back in the same hole soon, and when it does, raising taxes on those who can afford it the least won't work.
But this is what happens when you give the GOP total control of a state: guaranteed absolute fiscal disaster. The Nation's Kai Wright looks at the people who are suffering in Kansas under the Brownback administration, like RaDonna Kuekelhan and her sister Cathy O'Mara.
The sisters drove 30 miles from Cathy’s house down to the nearest CHC clinic, in Montgomery County’s largest town, Coffeyville. There, they met Julie Griffin, the doctor in charge. Griffin is also an evangelical minister, and as with many of the people I met in socially conservative southeast Kansas, Brownback’s politics force a tension in her core values. She’s resolutely pro-life and supports Brownback for his famously firm stance against abortion. But for her, valuing life means valuing universal access to healthcare, too. And she blames southeast Kansas’ ailing health on a toxic mix of poverty and political neglect.
“If you can’t find a job, you can’t feed your kids, you don’t feel like there’s any help for your kid in terms of success, that’s going to affect your mental health,” she says in a typically energetic riff about the challenges her patients face. “And if you don’t take care of your mental health, then your diabetes is going to be a thousand times worse.” She says much of her work is a matter of convincing patients to fight for their own lives, despite the dearth of care. She can call the roll of uninsured patients she’s coaxed away from preventable death, only to have them tumble back to grave illness when they grow defeated because she’s run out of subsidized meds or can’t connect them with a free specialist: “People that didn’t want to take care of their diabetes because there’s no hope anyways.”
Griffin immediately saw this grim potential in RaDonna and began scrambling. She sent the sisters on a 65-mile trek over the border to Joplin, Missouri, where she found specialists at a private hospital who would see RaDonna without insurance. “We went there for a year, back and forth,” RaDonna says. “We went to a throat doctor, went to a lung specialist, a stomach guy,” Cathy chimes in. Finally, they discovered the problem: All that radiation to clear RaDonna’s larynx cancer had destroyed her esophagus.
“The top of her throat is paralyzed,” Cathy explains. “Everything that she puts into her mouth and swallows, some of it aspirates down into her lungs. They told me that she is ‘terminal’—that was their words to me. ‘Your sister is terminal. We don’t know how long she will live. She will either slowly starve to death or she will aspirate and choke to death.’”
RaDonna was too young to collect Social Security, and she was trying to survive on a $231-a-month pension from Emerson. Despite her diagnosis and collapsing income, as a single adult she still didn’t qualify for Medicaid. The only way into Kansas’ program was to qualify for disability—and in 2013 the state rejected her application. “They denied it,” says Cathy, still angry. “They said she was not ill enough.”
Kansas is red state America at its finest: rejection of Obamacare grant money, full privatization of the state's Medicare program, massive tax cuts for "job creators" and budget cuts to get rid of "unnecessary spending", with a Republican supermajority in the state legislature and a GOP governor.
The results speak for themselves, don't you think?
This was a mess that could have been avoided. Of course, it's a lesson to all of us outside Kansas as well--that we need to quit it with the ridiculous "both parties are the same" twaddle and focus on the fact that people do better under Democrats and worse under the GOP (at least over the past 30-40 years).
ReplyDeleteSo it bears repeating--elections do matter. "Sitting it out" is a d**k move.
My relations in Kansas voted for none of this, but they are getting the rabbit punch all the same. Just like we have to suffer the burden of the joke states like Wyoming and Idaho, they have to carry the undue political weight of pathetic twarfs whose denizens would shoot Brownback for a DINO as soon as eat breakfast. The Republican embrace of their most extremist loons has brought success, but at a heavy price.
ReplyDeleteSo it has been interesting to watch the Sanderistas. The hysterical ninnies at the Daily Kos really are a base in this instance, they really are a significant component of his backing, but they have no idea what to do with themselves. Many a perfervid article, whipping the faithful into quasireligious state of exaltation, and breathless reports of BERNIE SAID THIS and BERNIE DID THAT but nothing in the way of organizing or pounding out a coherent platform or even generating white papers to explain how they intend to translate the beautiful slogans into effective legislative initiatives that address real issues: you know, work.
It's been great fun, in fact, watching them all be so enthusiastic. Kind of like the movie, Cocoon, if you remember that one. However, it's also very much like the Snowden hysteria in 2013: lots of excitement, mass expulsion of wrong thinkers, and rapid collapse of the entire jury rigged edifice after it becomes clear that no one is actually interested in putting in the time and money and expertise needed to make it all work over the long term.
So the question becomes, what do they do after Bernie bows out? Bernie himself, and the ninnies with character, are clear that they will support the ultimate Democratic nominee. Your typical gibbering idiot, on the other hand, will either slink back to his hidey and resume pretending 1968 never ended or go into HULK SMASH mode and try some petty scheme to get revenge on a world that has wronged him. What the split might be, nobody can say yet so the action point is further patient observation.
I am surprised that any GOP politicians are upset about this - it is performing as everyone knew it would. EVERYONE not financially involved in this KNEW it would do this, and for half of the people it is even better than they expected - the Blahs and the Poor are taking it on the chin, while the elite have their way cleared and lubricated for ease of sliding.
ReplyDeleteTHIS IS AS IT IS SUPPOSED TO BE - the People of Kansas WANTED this. All evidence to the contrary, they endorsed this plan to the point that there are SUPERMAJORITIES in both houses, and the (twice-elected) Governor is an economic sociopath.
So for Senator Jeff Longbine to spout off about how horrible it is smacks of either head trauma or deep-seated psychosis. ANY statement by a GOP official from Kansas that isn't a maniacal laugh with wringing hands straight from central casting is an embarrassment to the idea of politics, and that official should be shouted down and shunned.
Congratulations, Kansas GOP - you may have FINALLY killed the illusion that you were ever competent. Couldn't happen soon enough