Sunday, July 12, 2009

Dancing Around The Point

Frank Rich takes a look at the post-Palin resignation presser GOP and actually gets within touching distance of arriving at The GOP Plan, but he doesn't go all the way, dismissing them.

The essence of Palinism is emotional, not ideological. Yes, she is of the religious right, even if she winks literally and figuratively at her own daughter’s flagrant disregard of abstinence and marriage. But family-values politics, now more devalued than the dollar by the philandering of ostentatiously Christian Republican politicians, can only take her so far. The real wave she’s riding is a loud, resonant surge of resentment and victimization that’s larger than issues like abortion and gay civil rights.

That resentment is in part about race, of course. When Palin referred to Alaska as “a microcosm of America” during the 2008 campaign, it was in defiance of the statistical reality that her state’s tiny black and Hispanic populations are unrepresentative of her nation. She stood for the “real America,” she insisted, and the identity of the unreal America didn’t have to be stated explicitly for audiences to catch her drift. Her convention speech’s signature line was a deftly coded putdown of her presumably shiftless big-city opponent: “I guess a small-town mayor is sort of like a community organizer, except that you have actual responsibilities.” (Funny how this wisdom has been forgotten by her supporters now that she has abandoned her own actual responsibilities in public office.)

The latest flashpoint for this kind of animus is the near-certain elevation to the Supreme Court of Sonia Sotomayor, whose Senate confirmation hearings arrive this week. Prominent Palinists were fast to demean Sotomayor as a dim-witted affirmative-action baby. Fred Barnes of The Weekly Standard, the Palinist hymnal, labeled Sotomayor “not the smartest” and suggested that Princeton awards academic honors on a curve. Karl Rove said, “I’m not really certain how intellectually strong she would be.” Those maligning the long and accomplished career of an Ivy League-educated judge do believe in affirmative-action — but only for white people like Palin, whom they boosted for vice president despite her minimal achievements and knowledge of policy, the written word or even geography.
He's getting closer...

The politics of resentment are impervious to facts. Palinists regard their star as an icon of working-class America even though the Palins’ combined reported income ($211,000) puts them in the top 3.6 percent of American households. They see her as a champion of conservative fiscal principles even though she said yes to the Bridge to Nowhere and presided over a state that ranks No.1 in federal pork.

Nowhere is the power of resentment to trump reason more flagrantly illustrated than in the incessant complaint by Palin and her troops that she is victimized by a double standard in the “mainstream media.” In truth, the commentators at ABC, NBC and CNN — often the same ones who judged Michelle Obama a drag on her husband — all tried to outdo each other in praise for Palin when she emerged at the Republican convention 10 months ago. Even now, the so-called mainstream media can grade Palin on a curve: at MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” last week, Palin’s self-proclaimed representation of the “real America” was accepted as a given, as if white rural America actually still was the nation’s baseline.
Man Frank, if you got any closer to the truth you'd be on fire...

It’s more likely that she will never get anywhere near the White House, and not just because of her own limitations. The Palinist “real America” is demographically doomed to keep shrinking. But the emotion it represents is disproportionately powerful for its numbers. It’s an anger that Palin enjoyed stoking during her “palling around with terrorists” crusade against Obama on the campaign trail. It’s an anger that’s curdled into self-martyrdom since Inauguration Day.

Its voice can be found in the postings at a Web site maintained by the fans of Mark Levin, the Obama hater who is, at this writing, the No.2 best-selling hardcover nonfiction writer in America. (Glenn Beck is No.1 in paperback nonfiction.) Politico surveyed them last week. “Bottomline, do you know of any way we can remove these idiots before this country goes down the crapper?” wrote one Levin fan. “I WILL HELP!!! Should I buy a gun?” Another called for a new American revolution, promising “there will be blood.”
Dude, you're sitting on the volcano here. Make the leap.
These are the cries of a constituency that feels disenfranchised — by the powerful and the well-educated who gamed the housing bubble, by a news media it keeps being told is hateful, by the immigrants who have taken some of their jobs, by the African-American who has ended a white monopoly on the White House. Palin is their born avatar. She puts a happy, sexy face on ugly emotions, and she can solidify her followers’ hold on a G.O.P. that has no leaders with the guts or alternative vision to stand up to them or to her.
My God, has he finally seen the light for what the GOP has been up to for the last year? Can we make the connection that this is what the Republican Party is trying to do, to foment a race and culture war, with emphasis on the war part? Can somebody up there in Villageland finally speak truth to power, that the Republican Party has become a reactionary party of racism and violence, and that Sarah Palin and Rush Limbaugh are their face and voice respectively? Has Frank Rich finally gotten the point that the GOP has all but declared war on Those Who Dare Put Obama In The White House?

Has Frank Rich finally, finally gotten The GOP Plan?
For a week now, critics in both parties have had a blast railing at Palin. It’s good sport. But just as the media muttering about those unseemly “controversies” rallied the fans of the King of Pop, so are Palin’s political obituaries likely to jump-start her lucrative afterlife.
...no.

Article ends.

Frank Rich drives up to the edge of the abyss, but fails to call it what it is. Still, this is the closest I've seen anyone in the Village get to the obvious. Rich dismisses this all as a failed and cynical political strategy that might yet still help the GOP down the road. He couldn't be more wrong.

Millions of Americans believe this is war, or soon will be one. And the clock's ticking. They're not kidding when they talk about the revolution. They're not kidding when they say "somebody's got to take matters into their own hands." They're not kidding when they say "We need to arm ourselves."

They're deadly serious. And the GOP Pretty Hate Machine keeps whipping them up into a frenzy on an almost daily basis. If they start assigning messianic status to Sister Sarah there...who knows?

People keep underestimating the depth and pervasiveness of this movement. But it's out there. Millions of them running on emotion rather than logic. Millions of them who see a black man in the White House as the Beginning of the End Times. And their anger and resentment grows daily because it's being fed. It's not just talk, folks.

It's deadly serious.

No comments:

Related Posts with Thumbnails