Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Last Call

If you're going to read only one article on the CIA IG's report, make it Scott Horton's piece at Harper's, where he plainly makes the case that everything you know about the torture memos are wrong. The big section:
All trails lead to the Vice President’s office. At several points, redactions begin just when the discussion is headed toward the supervision or direction of the program and context suggests that some figure far up the Washington food chain is intervening. Moreover, as Jane Mayer recounts in Dark Side, Helgerson’s report was shut down when he was summoned, twice, to meet with Dick Cheney, who insisted that the report be stopped. Cheney had good reason to be concerned. This report shows that the vice president intervened directly in the process and ensured that the program was implemented. The OPR report likewise shows Cheney’s office commissioning the torture memos and carefully supervising the process. It is increasingly clear that torture was Dick Cheney’s special project and that he was personally and deeply involved in it. And the CIA report has some amazing nuggets that show Cheney’s hand. In 2003, after Jay Bybee departed OLC, Cheney struggled to have John Yoo installed as his successor, but ultimately John Ashcroft’s candidate, Jack Goldsmith, prevailed. Goldsmith quickly backtracked on the torture authorizations that Yoo and Bybee gave. The result? The CIA stopped taking its cue from OLC and instead turned to the White House for guidance. It is remarkably vague on the particulars, and blackouts emerge just as passages seem to be getting interesting. But there’s little doubt that Dick Cheney and his staff were pushing the process from behind the scenes.
Make no mistake, this is the Sum of All Fears for the Republican Party right here. The stakes are immense and they know it. If Dick Cheney goes down, all the GOP goes with him. They will not go without a fight for the ages.

The problem is, Obama and Holder don't have the stomach for this level of hardball. Obama's numbers continue to drop because he's getting bogged down on the defensive without any successes. That all changes should he get health care reform passed. But for now, it's a Sisyphean effort to keep rolling that boulder up the hill.

No comments:

Related Posts with Thumbnails