Monday, January 18, 2010

Contingency Plan

There is no plan to failure, only failure to plan, the saying goes.  The Dems in Massachusetts may have done both, frankly.  But now we're at least seeing a way forward for health care reform:
A new way forward on health care is gaining some traction among Democrats, who are preparing for the possibility that Democrat Martha Coakley will lose her bid to replace Ted Kennedy in the Senate, costing Democrats their 60th vote, which they'll need to overcome the filibuster.

The House has been preparing to tweak the Senate bill with a package of amendments based on a deal reached last week with organized labor, send it back to the upper chamber for final passage, and claim victory. But Coakley could well lose her race, depriving Democrats of the 60th vote they'd need to overcome a filibuster, and that unthinkable possibility is forcing party leaders to consider a Plan B.

As I noted last week, the House could simply pass the Senate bill unchanged, and Obama could sign reform into law. As recently as last week, a number of high-profile Democrats were saying that would never fly. But many are now suggesting that the House might still pull through, if House members are promised that the deal they agreed to last week will be passed separately--and quickly--through the filibuster-proof budget reconciliation process.

Jim Manley, spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, told the Boston Globe, the idea is "well within the scope of the rules of the Senate," and, indeed, the deal with labor is largely a change to the tax structure of the bill, which is the sort of issue the reconciliation process is designed to address.
My question is why not make the changes the House wants through reconciliation regardless of what Coakley does?  Take the "Lucy and the football" factor away from guys like Ben Nelson and Joe Lieberman altogether and do this anyway.

This should be the plan.  The Senate has done its damage.  It's time for the House to fix it.

No comments:

Related Posts with Thumbnails