A Real Lou-Lou Of A Debut

If you haven't been tuning in to CNBC's newest show after Maddow, The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell, you're missing some good stuff so far.  Lou Dobbs got his ass handed to him by Nation reporter Isabel McDonald, whose story on Dobbs -- a man who built a cable TV news career on bashing undocumented immigrants -- showed Dobbs himself hired undocumented immigrants as workers.

Dobbs and McDonald faced off on Last Word last night, and it was a hell of a thing.  Glenn Davis at Mediaite:

O’Donnell strictly mediated – this was Dobbs vs. McDonald. And the first thing to jump out about this segment: it was long, taking up half the program. McDonald thought Dobbs was “holding [him]self to a completely different standard than the standards that [he's] held all other American employers to,” while Dobbs thought her piece was “a hit job.” At the center of the debate was, seemingly, semantics: Dobbs seemed to be out to prove that he never “directly, knowingly employed any undocumented worker” (and MacDonald admitted she didn’t have evidence as such), while The Nation’s point wasn’t so much that Dobbs even indirectly employing undocumented workers would make him a hypocrite. (It’s even right in the title.)
In fact, as O’Donnell himself said to Dobbs at one point:

“Well, what they’re calling you on this case is a hypocrite if you did that. You do, what I’m agreeing to is you absolutely didn’t commit a crime if you did that. I’m agreeing to that. But when you take to the pulpit and preach what you preached you got to be, you got to understand why people think this is a hypocritical outcome.”

This gets at the heart of it: Dobbs at one point said, “If you want to hold me to…a different and higher standard, you go right ahead.” And that “different and higher standard” is the price of making illegal immigration a pet cause for so long. Dobbs also mentioned during the interview his ultimate goal is a “rational, effective, humane immigration policy.” That’s a tall order, and after The Nation’s piece – “hit job” or not – the pressure is on for him to contribute significant ideas toward just that.

Video here.  Not sure how long O'Donnell can keep up the fireworks at this level, but so far whoever's booking his show deserves a raise.  Worth staying up for after Rachel, if only to see O'Donnell take on everyone from Levi Johnston to Michael Steele...folks Olbermann and Maddow wouldn't be able to get as easily.