Absolutely Taxing My Patience

If you thought Simpson-Bowles was a stupid, cowardly plan that did nothing to deal with health care costs and made punishing cuts to Medicaid, Social Security, and cut taxes for the rich, well you're going to hate the Domenici-Rivlin plan.  Froomkin:

This latest group hails from the Bipartisan Policy Center, and its signature proposal may end up being a whopping 6.5 percent national "Deficit Reduction Sales Tax" -- just the sort of thing that is devastating to people who live on a budget while not really mattering so much to the rich.

In the name of allegedly controlling health care costs, the group also recommends significant increases in Medicare premiums in the short term. And after 2018, Medicare beneficiaries would either be forced to pay out of pocket for any and all cost increases more than one percent greater than the growth rate of the economy -- or they would be invited to leave the government program entirely and find private insurance instead. That would no longer be Medicare as we know it -- or as future retirees expect it.

The group's next most major recommendation for cutting healthcare spending is the imposition of an excise tax on the manufacture and importation of beverages sweetened with sugar or high-fructose corn syrup.

Like the plan from presidential commission chairmen Erskine Bowles and Alan Simpson, this one also would significantly reduce Social Security benefits for most retirees. It doesn't technically call for an increase in the retirement age, like Bowles-Simpson does, but it accomplishes essentially the same thing under another name.

This plan would "index the benefit formula for increases in life expectancy" starting in 2023. In both cases, the net result would be lower monthly benefits. It would also dramatically reduce benefits by changing the calculation of cost-of-living adjustments, and by chopping checks for top quarter of beneficiaries.

Meanwhile, much like Bowles-Simpson, it would actually lower income tax rates for the rich (albeit while removing hugely lucrative deductions). There would be two individual income tax rates, 15 percent and 27 percent, instead of the current six rates that range up to 35 percent. The corporate rate would drop to 27 percent from 35 percent. Capital gains would be taxed at a higher rate, as ordinary income.

Almost all deductions would be wiped away, including the deduction for employee-paid health insurance. The mortgage interest, charitable donation and retirement savings deductions would be replaced with a capped 15 percent credit.

Story continues below

Advertisement

In other words,  cut Medicare, cut Social Security, and add a national 6.5% sales tax on everyone just to pay for lowering taxes on the wealthy...and the plan does nothing to lower health care costs, only what the government is allowed to spend on health care.

Even worse than Simpson-Bowles, the Domenici-Rivlin plan would hammer the poorest 80% of America on food, clothing, and other everyday items and make them pay for more while the wealthiest would end up paying less to the government every year.

"Serious bipartisan deficit reduction" is code for "finish destroying the middle class".